The true meaning behind this passage has eluded me, and thus, is one of many questions I have for Paul to give more detail on what he really meant.
Creating, making, yes, using your heart to sing to Jesus. . . I get it. Sorta.
So, as I am standing in a service singing a praise song and I kinda start my own little harmony, singing in the Spirit (as Paul brings up in 1 Corinthians 14:15) and it sounds pretty good. (Even the idea of doing this sounds good). Singing a personal melody for God. Is this what Paul meant?
What if my lips and vocal cords do not move, thus, literally my heart is making the melody between the Lord and myself — an inaudible personal song. Is this what Paul was talking about?
Or is it a group thing, like communion, we all participate together at the same time. As a group we begin to Spiritually sing. ?
Maybe in the writing process the Spirit would lead those writing the song. As the theme modulates in weaving melody and words which will one day move worshipers during a service — those words and melody flowing from the heart. Is this it? This is the what I strive for as I write a song.
Maybe you have some more ideas?
I am fond of each of these ideas. I believe in the Spirit leading us as a group or as individuals in ways that show God in His True Light; perpetuating His story, His interactions with human beings. His way with ALL humans. His way with EACH human. His way with __________(insert your name here). His caring for each one of us. Even if we are not all musicians.
I believe it’s amazing! Could the answer be a pleasant mix of them all? Sometimes one way, sometimes another way?
I do wish Paul could clarify a few things.